March 2005

Balance the Books

March 2005 Cover

Mr. Bush, buoyed by his second inauguration and the ease with which his old friend, Margaret Spellings, was approved as Education Secretary, proposed his education budget for fiscal year 2006 last month. The President’s budget cuts overall spending on education for the first time in over a decade and proposes to eliminate funding for 48 programs, including Even Start and the Foreign Language Assistance Program.

Despite the extension of No Child Left Behind’s testing and accountability measures into high schools, the budget provides only $56 billion in education funding for the country; a decrease of $530 million or a one percent decrease over his fiscal year 2005 budget request. The proposals provide for only a $319 million total increase for No Child Left Behind programs nationwide.

If enacted, the President’s budget will make it much more difficult for our already struggling schools to meet the demanding standards set for students. Assessment and accountability are important tools in the maintenance of a successful public education system, but they are not the be all and end all. Currently, the federal government funds less than eight percent of the nation’s education program, but is able to demand a lot for its money because schools need every dime they can get.

Of particular relevance to us is the fact that for the third year running, there are no proposed increases in spending for English language learners, the most rapidly growing sector of public school enrollment. Title III would be “level funded” at $676 million.

The plan also calls for a 66 percent reduction in federal adult education funding nationwide. The U.S. Department of Education, Office of Vocational and Adult Education reports that in 1999, adults seeking English language and literacy instruction represented the largest segment (37 percent) of federally funded adult education enrollment. Following immigration patterns, it can be assumed that over half of all adult education enrollment is now for English language and literacy.

The proposed program cuts – if enacted by Congress – will have a disproportionate impact on language-minority students, be they children or adults.

Ironically, these proposals do very little to decrease the federal deficit, which is now at a record level of nearly $500 billion a year, thanks to burgeoning military expenditures and tax cuts for the wealthy.

In this issue, European Union Commissioner for Education, Ján Figel´ explains the EU’s goal of each citizen speaking “mother tongue plus two” languages which may seem over-ambitious even for Europe where expenditure on education averages almost three times that of the U.S. However, the European attitude is that such spending is a vital investment not only to secure the integration of the enlarged European Union, but to ensure its prosperity in a rapidly shrinking world.

We need to keep up with our competitors, learn from others and invest in our future. Con­tact your Congressional representatives, Demo­crat and Republican, and make sure that they know that you do not support this budget.


2005 / The Year of Languages
European Initiatives Commissioner Ján Figel describes Europe’s multilingual policy

Reframing Education
Sandra Mercuri and Denise Rea suggest innovative strategies to encourage English language learning with standards

Freedom to Speak
Karen Bond advocates chat rooms for shy ESL students

Revisiting the Ebonics Debate
Cindy McPhail assesses the role of Ebonics today

Partners in Language
Maria Jofre experiments with dual language for adults

Diversity as Subject and Object
David Dolson on a linguistic trilogy documented on film

Twisted English
Marta Menendez and Steven Donahue

Bilingual Chile?
Domenico Maceri explores state sponsored bilingualism

Last Writes
Richard Lederer and the Revenge of Anguished English